Nathan Wiley
Narrator (voice)

Cherise Silvestri
Narrator (voice)

Russell Bentley
Narrator (voice)

Gino Raimondo
Detective Mark Fleidner / Detective Ronald Flagg (uncredited) / Ralph (Gilbert) ...

Ann Smith
Miriam Aune / Corporal Beverly Ashton / Gina Nisbit

Dawn Sadler
Shelley Riley (Christina's Aunt/Guardian) / Anne Simenson

Avery Laine
Christina 'Chrissy' Long / Samantha Mann

Randy Starr
George Weber / Joe Nick (Missing Persons Investigator)

Jim Canale
Glenn Kallai / Timothy Goff

Will Conlon
Detective Chad Winn / Wade Ridley

David McConnell
Self - True Crime Author

Joshua Pivato
Eric / Saul Dos Reis

Bernadette Medhurst
Susan Croft / Dianne McKnight

Heath Hudson
Anthony Pasquale / Detective Randall Wortman (uncredited)

David Bacque
Detective Brian Tompkins / The Boss

Marta Legrady
Deb Bruce (David's Sister) / Grandma Peggy (uncredited)

Val Cole
Margaret 'Peg' Schobert / Mary Kay Beck

Zoe Brown
Shawna Lynch / Jess Wade

Antonino Pruiti
Norm / Brandon White (uncredited)

Bryan Edwards
Dean Strategos / Detective Mark Williams