Brenda Strong
Narrator (voice)

Jerry Rector
Det. Mark Clephane

Jackie Torres
Pamela / Sara Sanchez / Rita / Charle's Neighbor

Noah Staggs
Lead Detective / Detective Dove

Lawrence Moran
Det. John Decker / Detective John Decker

Hayes Mercure
Kevin

Barbara Mullinex
Self - Victim (archive footage)

Caitlin Rother
Self - True Crime Author

Lyn Riddle
Self - True Crime Author

Ernie Dorling
Self - True Crime Author

Lauren Nash
Kim Carpenter

Brad Slaughter
Buzz Clinton

Richard Neil
Dick Carpenter

Karen Pavlick
Cynthia Carpenter

Christanna Rowader
Beth Carpenter

Ashley Watson
Rebecca Carpenter

Kristen Watson
Rebecca Carpenter

Brian Bell
Mark Despres

Robin Burcell
Self - Crime Writer

Pamela Daly
Janet Duvardo