Elliott Gould
Harry Lewis (Present Day)

Susannah York
Sue Lewis (Present Day)

Kaye Ballard
Mrs. Lewis (1940's)

Michelle Pfeiffer
Sue Wellington (1940's)

Robert Hackman
Mr. Lewis (1940's)

Herbert Rudley
Mr. Wellington (1940's)

Marian McCargo
Mrs. Wellington (1940's)

Tallie Cochrane
Hooker (Present Day)

Patrick Wright
Pat the Cop (1940's)

Bonnie Paul
Hilary Lewis (Present Day)

Tony O'Dell
Donny Lewis (Present Day)

Ben Frank
Cabbie #1 (Present Day)

John Diehl
Beaver (1940's)

David Caruso
Neighborhood boy (uncredited)

Pete Schrum
Meatloaf (Present Day)

Marvin Katzoff
Como (1940's)

Alan Solomon
Max the Brain (1940's)

Daniel Davies
Meatloaf (1940's)

Mickey Cherney
Ben Herman (1940's)

Al Bordighi
Como's Father (1940's)