Robert Amaya
Pastor John

Isabella Antinori
Audience Member

Kaylyn Aznavorian
Mall Shoper

Thomas Lee Baker
Norm Steedy (as Tom Baker)

Sue Bean
Judith

Erin Bethea
Betsy

Arielle Bielicki
Mall Shopper

Luke Blevins
High School Student

Asia Christmas
Mall Shopper

Scotty Curlee
Bob Stern

Rachel Dartt
Swim Instructor (as Rachel Dart)

Daniel Ellis
Cort

Sarah Glass
Holly's friend

Dot Gregory
Swim Fitness Member (Dottie)

Lilianna Griffee
Congregation Member

Victoria Jackson
Barbara

Devon Key
Audience Member

Leland Klassen
Pendergrass

Max Morgan
Jack

Bryson Pitts
Sick Kid