Don Knotts
Dr. Jesse W. Heywood

Barbara Rhoades
Penelope 'Bad Penny' Cushings

Jackie Coogan
Matthew Basch

Ruth McDevitt
Mrs. Olive Heywood

Frank McGrath
Mr. Remington

Terry Wilson
Welsh

Carl Ballantine
Abel Swanson

Pat Morita
Wong

Robert Yuro
Arnold the Kid

Herb Voland
Dr. Friedlander

Fay DeWitt
Violet

Dub Taylor
Pop Cushings

Hope Summers
Celia

Dick Wilson
Black Eagle (Indian chief)

Don 'Red' Barry
Rev. Zachary Gant

Vaughn Taylor
Rev. Longbaugh

Ed Peck
Sheriff

Edward Faulkner
Marshal Sam Huggins

Arthur Space
Sheriff Tolliver

Greg Mullavey
Phelps - Dental Student