Erika Henningsen
Charlie Morningstar (voice)

Stephanie Beatriz
Vaggie (voice)

Alex Brightman
Sir Pentious (voice)

Keith David
Husk (voice)

Kimiko Glenn
Niffty (voice)

Blake Roman
Angel Dust (voice)

Amir Talai
Alastor (voice)

Joel Perez
Valentino (voice)

Jessica Vosk
Lute (voice)

Lilli Cooper
Velvette (voice)

Christian Borle
Vox (voice)

Brandon Rogers
Katie Killjoy (voice)

Krystina Alabado
Cherri Bomb (voice)

Jeremy Jordan
Lucifer Morningstar (voice)

Daphne Rubin-Vega
Carmilla Carmine (voice)

Mick Lauer
Additional Voices (voice)

Darren Criss
St. Peter (voice)

Patina Miller
Sera (voice)

Shoba Narayan
Emily (voice)

Sarah Stiles
Mimzy (voice)