Miranda Cosgrove
Carly Shay

Jennette McCurdy
Sam Puckett

Nathan Kress
Freddie Benson

Jerry Trainor
Spencer Shay

Noah Munck
Gibby Gibson / Gibby Gibson (archive footage)

Jeremy Rowley
Lewbert Sline / Lewbert Sline (voice) / Lewbert Sline (archive footage)

Reed Alexander
Nevel Papperman / Nevel Papperman (archive footage)

Colin Spensor
Wesley

Ethan Munck
Guppy Gibson / Guppy Gibson (archive footage) / 5-Year-Old Gibby

Tim Russ
Ted Franklin / Ted Franklin (archive footage) / Ted Franklin (voice)

Mindy Sterling
Francine Briggs / Francine Briggs (archive footage)

Mary Ann Springer
Wendy / Bad Girl

David St. James
Mr. Howard

Ryan Ochoa
Chuck / Chuck (archive footage)

Victoria Justice
Tori Vega / Shelby Marx / Shelby Marx (archive footage)

Lane Napper
Lane / Ernie (archive footage) / Dancing Teacher / Ernie

Sean Smith
Dr. Dresdin

Dre Swain
W.O.W. Fan #3 / / Abby / Toby's Mom (voice)

Joseph Buttler
Mr. Stern

Deena Dill
Charlotte Gibson