Gordon MacRae
Self - Host / Biff Grimes / Barry O'Day

Eddie Marr
Court Clerk / Snappy / Joe / John / Police Chief / Guard / Gillen / Jailer / Fra...

Gage Clarke
Tompkins / Mayor Patrick / Brenner / Mr. Westcott / Henry Totter / Colonel Burt ...

Isobel Elsom
Mrs. Forbes / Ethel / Miss Shoebridge / Mrs. Fishkettle / Mrs. West / Alice / Mr...

Gene Lockhart
Innkeeper / Evander Cobb / Leslie Hobbs / Samuel Fulton / David Keeney / O'Conno...

James Mason
Self - Host

Dayton Lummis
/ Evans / Bob Warren / Michael Townsend / Col. Picquart / Dr. Morrison / Captai...

Edmond O'Brien
Harry 'Steve' Morgan / Maj. Jepelo / Randall / Hal / Mr. Protis / Rorsford / Mik...

Laraine Day
Charlotte Vale / Louise Howell / Phyllis Dietrichson / Lynn / Claire Brandon / S...

George Chandler
Mr. Hollis / Joe / Newspaper Man / Fred / Edgar / Eustace Peabody /

Phyllis Thaxter
Anne / Karen / Diana Forbes / Julie / Sister Mary / Fran / Connie Ennis

Ellen Corby
Aunt / / Nurse / Martha / Harriet / Lavinia Penniman / Norah

Thomas Mitchell
Sam Partridge / Johnny Reynolds

Sam Partridge / Johnny Reynolds

Fay Bainter
Innkeeper's Wife / Annie Keeney / Mrs. Hughes / Mrs. Grier

Robert Preston
Phil Baxter / Isaac Eaton / Tom / Kelly / Dowey / Jed Kennedy

Pat O'Brien
Charley Hackett / Joe Crandall / Captain Barnaby / Tim Larkin / Eddie Gorman / G...

Diana Lynn
Honor / Ellen / Louise Franklin / Princess Maria / Singleton / Ruth Deeves

Maureen O'Sullivan
Self - Intermission Guest / Stella / Mary / Intermission Guest / Agnes Fisher

Ruth Hussey
Linda Carson / Polly Baxter / Meg / Harriet Craig / Irene / Kit Marlowe

J. Pat O'Malley
Griffin / Patrick / Watkins / Richard / Alf / London Bobby