Justin McElroy
Self / Taako Taaco / Chris Evergreen

Travis McElroy
Self / Magnus Burnsides / Jingle King

Griffin McElroy
Self / Angus McDonald / Business Person

Sydnee McElroy
Self / Tabitha Bigcity

Clint McElroy
Santa / Merle Highchurch

Teylor Smirl
Self / Flatwoods Monster / Tabitha's Sibling

Rileigh Smirl
Self

Rachel McElroy
Self

Tommy Smirl
Self

Teresa McElroy
Self / Girlboss

B. Dave Walters
Self

Hank Green
Self

Jean Grae
Self

Storm DiCostanzo
Self

Adam Brody
Self

Satine Phoenix
Self

Brennan Lee Mulligan
Self

Carol McElroy
Mrs. Claus

Ashly Burch
Self

Jonathan Coulton
Self