Molly C. Quinn
Sister Mary

Jake Horowitz
Benjamin

Hayley McFarland
Sister Agnes

Rachel True
Sister Ruth

Zandy Hartig
Sister Honey

Chris Browning
Father Black

Ben Hall
Father Donaghue

Mary Buss
Mother Superior

Chris Sullivan
Curly

Sean Gunn
Paul Satchimo

Cait Brasel
Sister Dodd

Cheryl McConnell
Sister Claude

Azrial Greene
Sister Mawd

Rita Scranton
Sister Gertrude

Ginger Gilmartin
Wanda

Bruce Davis
Earl

Van Quattro
Father Exley

Jacob Snovel
Pete (uncredited)

Lorri Bohnert
Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)

Garrett O'Brien
Grocery Store Shopper / Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)