Anne Hathaway
Self

Lin-Manuel Miranda
Self

Tracee Ellis Ross
Self

Ryan Dillon
Elmo (voice)

Eric Jacobson
Grover / Bert (voice)

Matt Vogel
Big Bird / Count von Count (voice)

Stephanie D'Abruzzo
Prairie Dawn / Mae (voice)

David Rudman
Cookie Monster (voice)

Peter Linz
Ernie (voice)

Martin P. Robinson
Telly Monster (voice)

Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
Abby Cadabby (voice)

Jennifer Barnhart
Zoe (voice)

Frankie Cordero
Rudy (voice)

Tyler Bunch
Louie (voice)

Carmen Osbahr
Rosita (voice)

Suki Lopez
Nina