Fredric March
Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley

Veronica Lake
Jennifer

Robert Benchley
Dr. Dudley White

Susan Hayward
Estelle Masterson

Cecil Kellaway
Daniel

Elizabeth Patterson
Margaret

Robert Warwick
J. B. Masterson

Georgia Backus
Older Woman (uncredited)

Charles Bates
Wooley's Son (uncredited)

Brooks Benedict
Country Club Guest (uncredited)

Billy Bevan
Puritan Vendor (uncredited)

Edward Biby
Spectator at Fire (uncredited)

Marie Blake
Purity Sykes (uncredited)

Monte Blue
Doorman (uncredited)

Aldrich Bowker
Justice of the Peace (uncredited)

Al Bridge
Second Prison Guard (uncredited)

Nora Cecil
Harriet Wooley (uncredited)

Ann Carter
Jennifer Wooley (uncredited)

Chester Conklin
Party Bartender (uncredited)

Gordon De Main
Man with Masterson on Radio (uncredited)