Fyvush Finkel
Narrator (voice)

Tommy J. Michaels
Aaron (voice) (as Tommy Michaels)

Ronn Carroll
Uncle Shlemiel (voice)

Tovah Feldshuh
Zlateh the Goat / Aunt Sarah / The Matchmaker (voice)

Stephen D. Newman
Darko the Sorcerer (voice) (as Steve Newman)

Ivy Austin
The Lantuch (voice)

Harry Goz
Gronam Ox (voice)

Lee Wilkof
Sender / Tudras (voice)

Chip Zien
Treitel / The Donkey (voice)

Larry Keith
Schmendrick / Voice Over (voice)

Lewis J. Stadlen
Lekish / Zeinvel / The Peddler (voice)

Laura Dean
Dana (voice)

Margery Gray
Dina (voice) (as Margery Gray Harnick)

Julia K. Murney
Dona (voice) (as Julia K. Murney)