Charles Collins
Jonathan Pride

Frank Morgan
Mayor Don Emilio Perena

Steffi Duna
Serafina Perena

Luis Alberni
Pamfilo (the Jailer)

Victor Varconi
Don Balthazar (Monterey Captain of the Guards)

Rita Hayworth
Specialty Dancer (uncredited)

Jack La Rue
Lt. Chago (Baltazar's Aide)

Alma Real
Blanca (Serafina's Maid)

William V. Mong
Tecolote (Old Indian)

Mitchell Lewis
Pirate Chief

Julian Rivero
Shepherd

John Eberts
Mozo

Eduardo Cansino Jr.
Specialty Dancer (uncredited)

Nora Cecil
Landlady (uncredited)

Jim Farley
Sailor (uncredited)

Cy Kendall
Bouncing Betty's Cook (uncredited)

Vera Lewis
Orville's Mother (uncredited)

Ellen Lowe
Miss Ponsonby (uncredited)

Pat Nixon
Dance-Class Student (uncredited)

Marjorie Reynolds
Dancer (uncredited)