Bill Moseley
Ari Hall

Kimberly Hamilton
Maia

LaKesha Lorene
Brenda

Jason Crowe
Clint (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

Jeff Pearson
Karl (“Land Grab” Section)

Dominick Wilkins
Leo (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

Brittany Rachelle Smith
Natalie (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

Jenna Ruiz
Ginnie (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

Bailey McBride
Sarah (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

Jason Smither
John (“Gruenwald House” Segment)

David Cyborski
Deputy 1 (“Land Grab” & “Gruenwald House” Segments)

Scott Blake
Hillbilly Monster / Creature in the Woods

Steven Durgarn
Gary Wilhoite (“Land Grab” Segment)

Kyle Putra
Missing YouTuber (“Land Grab” Segment)

Brandon Benz
Deputy 2

Michael R. Holford
Co-Worker ("Back Country" Segment)

Ryan Dafforn
Caller #3 (voice)

Chris Maker
Chris ("Back Country" Segment)

Whitney McClimans
Co-Worker 2 ("Back Country" Segment)

Stephanie Riley
Tammy (Land Grab Section)